The Myth of Black Confederate Soldiers

The Confederate Press

"[E]very life that has been lost in this struggle was an offering upon the altar of African Slavery"


 



 

The Charleston Mercury 
Nov. 12, 1864
Macon Telegraph 
January 6, 1865
The Charleston Mercury 
Jan.. 13, 1865
The Richmond Dispatch 
November 9, 1864

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


 

The Charleston Mercury

Volume LXXXV
CHARLESTON, S.C.,  SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 1864
 Number 12,216

The Employment of Slaves

 The African is of an inferior race, whose normal condition is slavery. Prone to barbarism, and incapable of any other state than that of pupilage, he is at his best estate as the slave of the enlightened white man of this country. All history, experience, and the closest observation and research for the truth have brought the people of these States to this conclusion; and it constitutes, in a moral point of view, the rock of their defence. But if the slavery of the Confederate States be not the best condition for the negroes amongst us - if they are fit for freedom, and manumission be a desirable improvement in their political status - an improvement which they may obtain as a reward for service - then the justification heretofore set up for holding them as slaves is false and unfounded. Then is the base of our institution but shifting sand, and the superstructure, unable to support the beating of the winds and waves, must fall.

We would owe an apology to our readers for these stale remarks, but for the extraordinary suggestion in the President's message to which these remarks are pertinent. The purchase of forty thousand male slaves by the Confederate Government, to be employed as teamsters, cooks and pioneer and engineer laborers, might possibly be judicious if properly managed, but to emancipate them afterwards, would not merely disturb the status of our negro population, but would go a great way to justify the arguments and views of the abolitionists, while it would give the lie to our professions and surrender the strength and power of our position. We cannot believe that a policy so inconsistent, unsound and suicidal can meet the sanction of any respectable body of Southern men. The liberation of slaves is against the laws of South Carolina, and we believe of most of the other Confederate States. It dooms them  to ruin, as it does in the United States.

 
 

          .
 
 
 

 
 
 


 

Macon Telegraph


January 6, 1865
 

Amid the storm of revolution, governments are apt to forget the principles to secure which they were instituted, and by which they should be controlled. All history admonishes us of this truth. . . ..It should be constantly kept in view, through all the bloody phases and terrible epochs of this relentless war, that slavery was the casus belli--that the principle of State Sovereignty, and its sequence, the right of secession, were important to the South principally, or solely as the armor that encased her peculiar institution--and that every life that has been lost in this struggle was an offering upon the altar of African Slavery. In the light of this great and solemn truth, is it not a matter of wonder and astonishment, that Southern men should gravely propose to arm, and as a necessary consequence, emancipate all the able-bodied slaves in the Confederacy, or a large portion of them, thereby striking an irretrievable and fatal blow at the institution. The adoption of this policy would be foul wrong to our departed heroes who have fallen in its defense. The compulsory adoption of such a policy would be tantamount to defeat; for what else is the forced assimilation of our institutions to those of the North but the abandonment of the whole object of the war ?.
 . . The advocates of this measure surely have not considered well the consequences likely to result from arming our slaves. Evidences are not wanting to illustrate the ill-suppressed discontent of many of our slaves in the past. The people seem to have grown over secure because of the unexpected subordination of our slaves during the war. They should remember that the whole white population being under arms, any uprising of the negroes was more than ever impracticable. How different might be the state of things, if they too were armed. They would be equal, perhaps superior, in numbers to our effective white force. What horrors might result from a general revolt? Yankees without and negroes within ! At best it is not to be expected that they would be more true than our white veterans, and if two-thirds of them should desert and disperse themselves over the country, co-operating with and led by bad men and deserters of long standing, how appalling would be our condition !
 Upon the whole, the proposition under consideration seems to be opposed by principle, consistency, self-respect, honor and safety.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


 

The Charleston Mercury

Volume LXXXVI
CHARLESTON, S.C., FRIDAY, JANUARY 13, 1865.
Number 12,266 

Lunacy
   The wild talk prevalent in the official and the semi-official organs at Richmond grates harshly upon the ear of South Carolina.  It is still more grievous to her to hear the state unmanly proposition from those in authority in the old State of Virginia. Side by side Carolina and Virginia have stood together against all-comers for near two centuries-the exemplars and authors of Southern civilization. Side by side it is our earnest hope they will stand to all time against the world.  But we grieve to say there are counsels now brewing there that South Carolina cannot abet-that she will not suffer to be consummated, so far as she is concerned in them.

...

   In 1860, South Carolina seceded alone from the old union of States.  Her people, in Convention assembled, invited the slaveholding  States (none others) of the old Union to join her in erecting a separate Government of Slave States, for the protection of their common interests.  All of the slave States, with the exception of Maryland and Kentucky, responded to her invitation.  The Southern Confederacy of slave States was formed.
   It was on account of encroachments upon the institution of slavery by the sectional majority of the old Union, that South Carolina seceded from that Union.  It is not at this late day, after the loss of thirty thousand of her best and bravest men in battle, that she will suffer it to be bartered away; or ground between the upper and nether mill stones, by the madness  of Congress, or the counsels of shallow men elsewhere.

   By the compact we made with Virginia and the other States of this Confederacy, South Carolina will stand to the bitter end of destruction.  By that compact she intends to stand or to fall.  Neither Congress, nor certain make-shift men in Virginia, can force upon her their mad schemes of weakness and surrender.  

 She stands upon her institutions--and there she will fall, in their defence.  We want no Confederate Government without our institutions.  And we will have none.-Sink or swim, live or die, we stand by them, and are fighting for them this day.  That is the ground of our fight-it is well that all should understand it at once.  Thousands and tens of thousands of the bravest men, and the best blood of this State, fighting in the ranks, have left their bones whitening on the bleak hills of Virginia in this cause.  We are fighting for our system of civilization-not for buncomb, or for JEFF DAVIS.  We intend to fight  for that, or nothing.  We expect Virginia to stand beside us in that fight, as of old, as we have stood beside her in this war up to this time.  But such talk coming from such a source is destructive to the cause.  Let it cease at once, in God's name, and in behalf of our common cause!  It is paralizing to every man here to hear it.  It throws a pall over the hearts of the soldiers from this State to hear it.  The soldiers of South Carolina will not fight beside a nigger-to talk of emancipation is to disband our army. We are free men, and we chose to fight for ourselves-we want no slaves to fight for us.  Skulkers, money lenders, money-makers, and blood-suckers, alone will tolerate the idea.  It is the man who won't fight himself, who wants his nigger to fight for him, and to take his place in the ranks.  Put that man in the ranks.  And do it at once.  Control your armies-put men of capacity in command, re-establish confidence-enforce through discipline-and there will be found men enough, and brave men enough, to defeat a dozen SHERMAN'S.  Falter and hack at the root of the Confederacy-our institutions-our civilization-and you kill the cause as dead as a boiled crab. 
   The straight and narrow path of our deliverance is in the reform of our government, and discipline of our armies.  Will Virginia stand by us as of old in this rugged pathway?  We will not fail her in the shadow of a hair.  But South Carolina will fight upon no other platform, than that she laid down in 1860.

 

     
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


 

The Richmond Dispatch 


November 9, 1864
 

   We have forborne to take any part in the discussions relative to the making soldiers of our slaves because it had not yet been formally proposed as a practical question, and we had hoped that it would be passed over. We did not wish to create a breach at a time when harmony is so desirable. As the discussion is to be forced upon us, however, we wish to express our opposition, and the grounds thereof in as few words as we can.
    The proposition, in the first place, is totally unconstitutional. We parted from the Old Government because of its determined purpose to interfere in the domestic affairs of the States. Were we still under that Government, engaged in a war with all Europe, and invaded by a million of men, surely nobody will contend that the General Government would possess the power; under the pretext of necessity, to abolish slavery in the States by making soldiers of the slaves;for such is the undoubted effect of that measure. Now, we are not aware that the Confederate Government has any powers which the Federal Government had not.
   Second. Let it be conceded that the constitutional power exists. The exercise of it is, nevertheless, a confession of weakness, or rather a profession of a weakness which does not exist. We have no occasion to resort to any such extreme measure. Our affairs are in a better condition, and our prospects brighter, than they ever have been since the commencement of the war.
  Third. Armies must be fed, and in order to feed them crops must be made. The negroes are our agricultural laborers. Take them from farm-work, and you destroy the army more effectually than Grant can do it with a million of men to back those he has in the field.
  Fourth. It -would be a powerful stimulant to recruiting for the Yankees. There can be no doubt that a vast number would 
resort to them who are restrained at present by the apprehension of being forced into the ranks. They stay at home because they are in no danger. Let them see that it is as dangerous to stay as to go, and they will be pretty certain to go. For, with the Yankees, they get a high bounty for enlisting, and liberty and equality into the bargain. The services are set before them which of the two to choose, and there will, we fancy, be little hesitation as to the choice.  
  Fifth. We give up the whole question when we adopt this measure. Whatever we may be fighting for, the Yankees are fighting for "the nigger"; that is, to abolitionize the South. We are not disposed to gratify them if we can avoid it. Henry Ward Beecher, in one of his speeches, made about a year ago, boasted that slavery had received a mortal blow, and that this war would be the means of spreading "New England ideas," that is, abolitionism, Fourierism, free-loveism, and the whole brood of Yankeeisms, throughout the continent. These ideas, he concluded, would make a surer conquest than the sword.
   The Numantians of old won immortal renown by burning up their city, their wives and children, and themselves, rather than be subjugated. If we are reduced to the same extremity, perhaps it will be well to make soldiers of our negroes; for it seems to us that the one is about as much an act of desperation as the other. But we deny that we have come to that point, or are likely to come to it.
   The proposition of the Confederate Executive to introduce a larger number of blacks into the public service, as teamsters and laborers, cannot be reasonably objected to. There will be some division on the subject of setting free after the war such as are purchased by the Government for these purposes. It is to be hoped that the discussion of the matter will not be indulged to an unnecessary length, and that the action of the Government will be at once prudent and practical.